The Fed hiked, the market flinched, then shrugged
S&P +1.1% as tech led a relief rally after the first Fed rate hike in three years
Theme
Yesterday's panic was about not knowing. Today's rally is about knowing.
The Session
Stocks bounced back on Thursday, more than making up for the Federal Reserve decision-driven downturn seen in the prior session. The tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite led gains, up 1.7% to roughly 26,420. The S&P 500 rose 1.1% to about 7,635.
The Dow added 0.6%, or 317 points. All three snapped a three-day losing streak.
The move reversed Wednesday's session, when the Fed delivered its first rate hike since 2023, a quarter point that took the benchmark rate to 3.75% to 4%. Chairman Kevin Warsh called it 'removing a dose of accommodation,' and stocks slid on the implication that more hikes are coming. Traders now put a coin flip on another hike in October.
Thursday's bounce got help from the tape, not the Fed. Initial jobless claims fell to 196,000, below estimates, a reassuring read on the labor market. The 10-year Treasury yield retreated seven basis points to 4.94%, backing off the 5% mark it touched earlier in the week.
Oil drifted lower on Iran War de-escalation news, easing some of the energy inflation anxiety. Technology gained more than 2%, the day's best sector.
Why It Moved
The obvious question, here and always, is: what did the market learn between Wednesday's close and Thursday's open? Nothing. It learned nothing.
The Fed said nothing new. Warsh made no fresh speeches. The rate is still 3.75% to 4%.
And that is the whole mechanism. Markets do not price levels, they price uncertainty. The logic runs like this: (1) Before a big known event, everyone hedges, because the range of outcomes is wide.
(2) Once the event lands, the range collapses to a single point. Even a hawkish point. (3) The hedges come off, and stocks rise on the removal of fear, not the addition of good news.
It is why the same headline can cause a selloff on Wednesday and a rally on Thursday. On Wednesday, 'Fed hikes' meant 'who knows how many more. ' On Thursday, 'Fed hiked' meant 'probably one more, in October, and we have priced that.
' Same information, different uncertainty, opposite reaction.
There is a deadpan version of this on every trading desk in the world. Investor: 'I am terrified of the Fed. ' Desk: 'The Fed just did the thing.
You can be terrified of the next thing now. ' Investor: 'When is the next thing. ' Desk: 'October 28, five days before the midterms.
' Investor: 'I am terrified again. ' And so it goes.
The market did not rally because the hike was good. It rallied because the hike was done.
The Names
Tomorrow
- The 10-year yield and the 5% line. It backed off to 4.94% today; a retest of 5% would put the day's relief on trial.
- Friday's options expiration. Third Friday of the month, and September brings quadruple witching, which has a habit of adding volatility to whatever the market already decided.
- Iran War headlines. De-escalation news helped pull oil off its highs today; any reversal would hand the inflation hawks their argument back.
