Oil fell, yields didn't, and Williams did the talking
The 10-year touched 5.29%, a 19-year high, while stocks closed lower for a second day.
Theme
Crude fell, yields wouldn't, and the tape only breathed when a Fed president talked.
Thesis check
- ☐ S&P 500 prints a fresh record close this week
- ☐ Fed hikes a quarter point at the October meeting
- ☐ Brent settles below $100 by Friday's close
- ☐ Wednesday's PCE cools the October-hike odds
- ☐ TSLA closes the week above $380 (deliveries Friday)
- ☐ 10-year holds below Monday's 5.27% intraday peak through Friday's close
The Session
Tuesday was a slow bleed that almost turned. The S&P 500 fell 0.2% to 7,668, the Dow lost 0.3%, and the Nasdaq slipped 0.1%. All three closed lower for the second straight day, but that undersells the afternoon.
Stocks were deeper in the red at midday and clawed most of it back after New York Fed president John Williams said the central bank does not have to be urgent about raising rates. October hike odds fell from 71% to 52% on the remark.
The setup was supposed to be friendlier than Monday. Brent crude fell 2.6% to about $103 a barrel after Saudi Arabia pushed more oil through its East-West pipeline, and WTI dropped 3.6% to $89. Oil was the villain on Monday.
On Tuesday it left the scene and the market kept falling anyway.
The Leash Held
This morning's call: The bounce is rented. Stocks close Tuesday lower as the rate-oil vise keeps every rally on a short leash into Wednesday's PCE.
Confirmed. All three indexes closed lower for a second straight day: the Dow down 0.3%, the S&P 0.2%, the Nasdaq 0.1%. The 10-year never got near the 5.15% line that would have broken the call; it touched 5.29% intraday and closed at 5.26%.
The premarket chip bid faded too, with Nvidia closing down 0.7%, and the tape never greened into the close. The vise did exactly what the morning said it would.
What it sets up: The leash now runs through Wednesday's 8:30 a.m. PCE print; a cool number is the only thing that loosens it.
Why It Moved
The obvious question, here and always, is why falling oil did not save stocks. Monday's chain was oil to inflation to yields to lower prices. On Tuesday the first link broke and the rest of the chain held anyway.
That tells you the bond market has stopped trading the oil price and started trading the Fed.
Here is the plumbing. The 2-year yield is a bet on where the Fed's policy rate goes next, so it twitches when a Fed president speaks. The 10-year yield is a bet on inflation over a decade, plus the extra rent investors charge for locking money up that long, so it twitches on oil, deficits, and data.
On Tuesday the two ends of the curve filed for divorce. Williams talked the 2-year down. The 10-year touched 5.29%, its highest since 2007, and closed at 5.26%, its highest close in more than 24 years.
The 30-year closed at 5.59%, its highest since 2002. The long end looked at cheaper oil and decided the inflation story had not changed.
Investor: "But oil is down 3%." Bond market:
The Fed hiked two weeks ago, October is priced at a coin flip, and nothing in the data says cool it. Call me Wednesday.
The split screen explains the stubbornness. The soft data is ugly. Consumer confidence fell to 81.9 in September, its lowest since 2014.
The hard data is fine. Job openings came in at 7.1 million, a touch light of expectations and still a number that describes an economy with plenty of jobs. The bond market believes the hard data.
Until Wednesday's PCE gives it a reason not to, the long end has no incentive to rally. The vise the morning brief described tightened from the other side today. Not oil pushing yields up, but yields refusing to come down.
The Names
Tomorrow
- August PCE at 8:30 a.m. ET. The Fed's preferred inflation gauge is the whole trade now. A cool print revives the case that 5.26% is the top and reprices October; a hot one puts 5.29% back in play by lunch.
- The 10-year at 5.29%. That intraday peak is the line in the sand. A break above it is the bond market declaring the 2007 highs are next, and growth stocks will price it instantly.
- Micron earnings after the close. Memory was Tuesday's bounce; Micron's read on chip demand decides whether the AI bid is rotating or just resting. Jobless claims land Thursday morning, payrolls Friday.
