PCE came in cool. The bond market sold off anyway.
PCE cooled to 3.4% and the 10-year still hit a 24-year high of 5.30%.
Theme
The bond market overruled the inflation report: PCE cooled to 3.4%, but the 10-year hit a 24-year high of 5.30% and stocks surrendered their morning rally.
Thesis check
- ☐ Fed hikes a quarter point at the October meeting
- ☐ Brent settles below $100 by Friday's close
- ☐ Wednesday's PCE cools the October-hike odds
- ☐ TSLA closes the week above $380 (deliveries Friday)
- ☐ September payrolls print soft (100k or fewer new jobs) on Friday
The Session
The strangest trade of the day was the one the bond market refused to make. August PCE printed 3.4% headline and 3.0% core, the coolest readings since February, thirty basis points below expectations on both. By midday the S&P was up 0.6% and October hike odds had been cut nearly in half.
Then the 10-year Treasury yield touched 5.304%, past the 2007 peak, its highest since May 2002, and the rally died. The S&P finished down 0.25% at 7,651.54. The Dow fell 0.9%, about 441 points, to 50,906.05.
The Nasdaq held on, up 0.2% to 26,861.06.
September is over, and it was a month to forget for everything except megacap tech. The S&P lost 0.5%, the Dow fell 4.3% and snapped a five-month winning streak, while the Nasdaq gained 1.9%. For the quarter, the S&P rose 2% and the Nasdaq 2.5%; the Dow fell 2.7%.
The bond market's quarter was historic in the other direction: the 10-year posted its largest quarterly gain since the first quarter of 1994.
PCE Day Report Card
This morning's call: The October hike dies today: August PCE prints at or under 3.7% headline, the 10-year stays below its 5.29% high, and the S&P closes the quarter green.
Split. The inflation leg confirmed cleanly: headline PCE printed 3.4% and core 3.0%, both thirty basis points under expectations and the lowest since February, and October hike odds fell to 37% from 71% a week ago. The quarter leg held too: the S&P finished Q3 up 2%.
But the bond-market leg broke. The 10-year did not stay below 5.29%; it touched 5.304% intraday, past the 2007 peak, its highest since May 2002. And the hike did not die, it moved: the market now prices December.
The morning's headline claim was too strong by one month.
What it sets up: Tonight's split verdict sets up tomorrow's question: whether 5.30% is the top in yields or the bond market keeps voting against the Fed, with Friday's payrolls and Tesla's deliveries deciding the next leg.
Why It Moved
The obvious question, here and always, is why stocks fell on good inflation news. Here is the chain. (1) The inflation report was genuinely soft: headline PCE printed 3.4% against 3.7% expected, core printed 3.0% against 3.3% expected, and July was revised lower too.
Both are the coolest readings since February. (2) But the rest of the morning's data was hot: second-quarter GDP was revised up to 2.2% from 1.5%, private payrolls added 90,000 in September against 68,000 expected, and the Chicago PMI surged to 58.8. (3) So the bond market did the arithmetic the stock market would not: a hot economy plus sticky energy prices, gasoline alone jumped 4.4% in August, means the Fed may have to keep going even as inflation cools.
The 10-year went to 5.30% because the bond market is pricing a December hike, not an October one. This morning the odds did not die. They moved.
One detail worth knowing: some of that cooling was the BEA moving the goalposts. The August release carried a methodology change in how it prices software, portfolio management fees, and legal services, with revisions reaching back to 2021. Barclays flagged it.
The inflation report got cooler partly because the measurement changed, which is a fun thing to remember the next time anyone says data is objective.
And the plumbing, since that is the actual mechanism. A stock is worth the present value of its future cash flows, and the 10-year yield is the discount rate in that math. When the risk-free rate hits 5.3%, every future dollar of earnings is worth less today, which is why the equal-weight S&P sank while a handful of AI names held the cap-weighted index near breakeven.
Good inflation news only helps stocks if it lowers the discount rate. Today it didn't.
The Names
Tomorrow
- Micron after the beat-and-raise: $33.42 in quarterly EPS on $54 billion of revenue, guidance above the Street, and the stock sat flat after hours. Thursday's chip tape decides whether the AI-memory trade has another leg or the peak-cycle skeptics were right to stay seated.
- The 10-year at 5.29%, a 24-year high, with quarter-end flows behind it. The new quarter starts tomorrow; watch whether buyers show up or the bond rout resumes, because everything in equities now answers to that number.
- Weekly jobless claims Thursday, the last labor read before Friday's payrolls report, where 100,000 new jobs are expected. ADP's 90,000 beat and the GDP revision have the too-hot camp armed; a soft claims print is the doves' last hope.
