29,000 jobs, a green Friday, and the Fed hike fades
Payrolls missed by 55,000. Stocks cheered. October hike odds fell to 23 percent.
Theme
A soft September jobs report took the October Fed hike off the table, and Wall Street did its favorite trick: cheering bad news, while the bond market was not sure it agreed.
Thesis check
- ☐ Fed hikes a quarter point at the October meeting
- ☐ Brent settles below $100 by Friday's close
- ☐ TSLA closes the week above $380 (deliveries Friday)
- ☐ September payrolls print soft (100k or fewer new jobs) on Friday
- ☐ 10-year yield finishes the week under 5.35%
- ☐ Amazon's $8B Nvidia chip SPV gets a confirmed structure by Friday's close
The Session
Nobody on Wall Street was hoping for a strong jobs report, and nobody got one. The September payrolls landed at 8:30 with 29,000 new jobs against 84,000 expected, August revised down to 133,000, and unemployment ticking to 4.2 percent. The S&P 500 opened up nearly a percent, faded, and closed up 0.7 percent near 7,720.
The Dow added 0.5 percent, 251 points. The Nasdaq climbed 1.2 percent, touching a record intraday on its way to a third straight winning week. Both the Dow and the S&P still finished the week lower, down 1.3 and 0.3 percent.
The bond market staged the day's second act. The 10-year yield dropped to 5.16 percent right after the report, then spent the rest of the day climbing back to 5.28 percent, up about five basis points from Thursday. Traders cut the odds of an October Fed hike to 23 percent, from 28 before the reading and 64 a week ago.
Ten of eleven S&P sectors finished green, with consumer discretionary up over 1 percent. Only health care finished red, by a rounding error.
Payrolls Day, Graded
This morning's call: Friday closes green on a soft payrolls print. Anything at or below the 84,000 consensus takes the October hike back off the table and lets this week's rate tantrum fade into the weekend.
Confirmed. Payrolls printed 29,000, unemployment rose to 4.2 percent, and wage growth cooled to 0.1 percent, nowhere near the 120,000 or hot-wages triggers in the morning's wrong_if. The S&P closed up 0.7 percent and October hike odds fell to 23 percent.
The one wrinkle: the 10-year clawed back to 5.28 percent by the close, so the 'rate tantrum' faded less than the equity tape suggests. Confirmed on the letter, slightly less on the spirit.
What it sets up: Monday is the bond market's appeal of this verdict: if the 10-year holds below 5.35 percent, the morning's read on the cycle stands.
Why It Moved
The obvious question, here and always, is why anyone would celebrate 29,000 new jobs. The answer is the discount rate, and it helps to spell out the plumbing. (1) A hot labor market keeps wage growth warm.
(2) Warm wages keep inflation sticky, and sticky inflation gives the Fed its excuse to keep hiking. (3) A hike raises the rate at which every future dollar of corporate profit gets discounted, and that lands hardest on growth stocks, whose profits live furthest in the future.
So Friday's number was not really a jobs report. It was a permission slip. Payrolls at 29,000 against 84,000 expected, unemployment up to 4.2 percent, and wage growth of 0.1 percent told traders the Fed can stay parked in October.
Hike odds fell to 23 percent from 64 a week ago, and the bid went straight to the names that suffered most when the 10-year touched 5.35 percent on Thursday.
But the bond market added an asterisk. After dropping to 5.16 percent on the print, the 10-year climbed all the way back to 5.28 percent by the close. Bond traders read the same report and concluded it was not weak enough to force the Fed's hand, just weak enough to let stocks hope.
Stocks believed the report; bonds believed their own eyes. When equities and rates disagree about what a number means, the argument usually continues on Monday.
The Names
Tomorrow
- The 10-year's Monday move. The post-payrolls relief in yields was given back by the close; 5.35 percent, Thursday's 24-year high, is the line. If the bond market re-tests it, Friday's rally was a loan, not a gift.
- The rival bidder for Synaptics. ON Semiconductor switched its stock deal to $123 cash after an unnamed third party showed up, and shares added another 13 to 16 percent after hours. Anything above $123 is the tell.
- Oil's two directions. The G7 agreed to release 100 million barrels of crude and diesel stockpiles, which pushed WTI under $92, while front-month Brent still settled over $100. Which one holds tells you whether the energy crunch is easing or being managed.
