Nvidia beat, then the Fed minutes took it back
Nvidia gave back its pop, the S&P closed red, and the minutes backed a December hike.
Theme
Nvidia delivered the quarter everyone was waiting for, and the Fed minutes took it back.
Thesis check
- ☐ Anthropic trades above its IPO price on its Thursday debut
- ☐ Walmart's Thursday report keeps the consumer story intact
- ☐ Anthropic prices at or above the top of its range tonight
- ☐ FOMC minutes leave December-hike odds above 90% after today
The Session
The puzzle at the close: Nvidia printed the best quarter in its history, and the market spent the day handing it back. The stock opened higher on the beat, faded all afternoon, and closed below Tuesday's finish. The S&P slipped with it, a fifth straight down day.
The Nasdaq still finished higher, up about half a percent, carried by the names that had nothing to do with chips. The Dow fell hardest, down about a percent, as the stocks most sensitive to rates took the afternoon worst.
The Beat That Bounced Off
This morning's call: The S&P closes green Wednesday, led by chips, as Nvidia's beat breaks the four-day slide.
Broken. The S&P closed red, and Nvidia gave back its premarket gain to finish below Tuesday's close. Both conditions in the morning's wrong_if hit in the same session.
The beat was real and the tape still said no, because the minutes at 2 p.m. made the rate story the day's story.
What it sets up: Tomorrow's thesis starts from the rate story, not the earnings story: Anthropic's debut and Walmart's report test whether anything else can move the tape.
Why It Moved
The day had two events, and the second one won. Nvidia's quarter was a record by every measure that fits in a headline. Revenue more than doubled from a year ago, and the guide for next quarter beat what analysts expected.
The stock popped after hours Tuesday, opened higher Wednesday, and then spent the whole session giving it back.
The minutes from the Fed's October meeting landed at 2 p.m. Almost all officials backed a December hike. A couple floated a move bigger than the usual quarter point, and one governor had called for half a point earlier in the day.
The market had spent four days pricing in a disaster on rates. The minutes said the disaster is still on schedule.
The obvious question, here and always, is why a record quarter loses to a meeting summary. A stock is worth its future profits, discounted back to today. When the discount rate rises, those future profits are worth less now, and the stocks priced on the furthest-out profits fall first.
Nvidia raised the numerator. The Fed raised the denominator.
Investor: "But the quarter was a record. " The minutes: "December is a hike. Maybe more than a hike.
" The tape sided with the minutes.
The Names
Tomorrow
- Anthropic prices tonight and starts trading Thursday, the biggest AI IPO on record, with orders reportedly seven times covered.
- Walmart reports before the open, the last big consumer read before Black Friday.
- Jobless claims and the Philly Fed land in the morning, and Palo Alto's after-hours pop gets its first full session.
